Search This Blog

Showing posts with label reflections. Show all posts
Showing posts with label reflections. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 10, 2005

Archive of Readings

Hello, This blog contains an archive of my readings and thoughts for an Introduction to Instructional Technology Class. I will not be updating this blog again, but will leave it online as an archive of my writings. At some point, if blogger decides to offer categories, I will collapse all of my IT blogs into one large blog, with the classes creating the categories. If you would like to contact me about anything that you read on my blogs, please email me at robinsartnest@yahoo.com

To catch up on my latest news & projects, check out
http://robin-news.blogspot.com/

Tuesday, November 30, 2004

Assignment 29: Reading: The Media Education Elephant

http://interact.uoregon.edu

/MediaLit/mlr/readings/articles/tyner/elephant.html


Basically, this article talks about the history of media literacy and how political and social issues have impacted it from funding to the perception of it by practitioners. The author compares Media Literacy/IT to the "blind man and elephant" fable in that it does not have just one component and practice but many.



In times of economic downturn, it seems that media literacy (like many other "fringe" educational elements from the art to music to pe) are pushed to the side because they are deemed less important than the basic "3 Rs". The protectionists try to continue to promote standards of materials, especially in regards to programs aimed at a younger audience. As a side benefit, the protectionists are also concerned about the impacts of programming (especially) television as it relates to children's mental and physical health.



The author also discusses the rise of technical education (formerly known as vocational education). The end goal of technical education can be summed up in the word "job readiness." Partnerships with corporations are mutually useful in that it provides materials to schools in desparate need of funding and it gives the corporation a chance to influence its potential future workforce (as an added bonus, it may also help establish brand loyalty, even at a young age)



I think the rise in Technical education in the US is very interesting. It seems that some of the Technical Institutes/Universities advertise heavily on TV ; they tout the short amount of time to finish the programs and the "big bucks" payoff --money, prestige, etc. Little is said abount true learning or even what the student might learn. In fact a least one ad that I saw a few months ago compared a University degree to wasting time, vs. a Technical degree (a real degree).



Models that the author discusses are school/media specialists, video production, and museum programs (media arts)





Tuesday, November 16, 2004

Assignment 28: Reading: Media Comparison Research

http://www.gsu.edu/~mstswh/courses/it7000/papers/media.htm

Media Comparison Research

The author points out that many believe that there has been a shift in education from instructional media research from behavioral to cognitive.



He defines Media as

  • refer[ing] to a class of instructional resources and representing all aspects of the mediation of instruction through the agency of reproducible events. It includes the materials themselves, the instruments used to deliver the materials to learners and the techniques or methods employed. (Allen 1)
  • defined by its technology, symbol systems and processing capabilities. The most obvious characteristics of a medium are its technology: the mechanical and electronic aspects that determine its function and, to some extent, its shape and other physical features. (Kozma 180)

Media Research is based in

  • obtain knowledge about the educational or instructional effectiveness of a chosen medium
  • increase understanding of how media and technology function and what psychological effects they have on a learner
  • improve the practice of education through the provision and evaluation of better materials, media, procedures and technologies (Salomon, Clark 1-2).

This article revisits many of the Kozmo(medium important)/Clark(medium not important) argument and discusses the impact of research results on ongoing research.



Assignment 27: Reading: The attack on ISD

http://www.nwlink.com/%7Edonclark/history_isd/attack.html

This week's readings could just as well be called IT hangover. :)



Perrsonally, all of the articles in this week's reading, just seem like an expected backlash. Before people change a habit (or way of doing something) there is often a big flurry of regression/nostalgia for the old way. I think that is completely true with what is happening with technology. There is a psychological term for this, but I am odds to remember.



Basically, this article discusses how the ISD module is outdated and that the harder you try to describe how it should be done, the further you get from the realilty. Kind of like if you try to describe infinity...the more words you put on it the further you get from the reality of it. There will never be enough words to describe it.



Anyhow, back to the article. Sorry, I know I am rambling. I really am very tired.

Four major charges are brought against the model:

  • ISD is too slow and clumsy to meet today's training challenges.
  • There no 'there' there.
  • Used as directed, it produces bad solutions.
  • It clings to the wrong world view.
This kind of reminds me of what I do, or at least one component of what I do in my daily work. On the surface cataloging seems like a very easy thing to do, you take an item, determine it's "aboutness" based upon a certain criteria and add those keywords in. Sounds simple enough, hmm? Well, there's many wrong ways to do as well as many right ways to do it. Sometimes, it is a matter of determining which is the best way, but perhaps, not the right way. One can learn cataloging relatively quickly; however, to understand it, to be able to synthesize the rules, standards, and practices requires many years of experience. Even the best cataloger can make a bad decision.



To add to that analogy, Cataloging is often seen as an outdated practice. With keywords and metadata who needs cataloging? Well, those are forms of the cataloging concept as is any organizational structure. While the ISD module may need some tweaking, the concepts inherent to it will continue to remain valuable. It's taking the fundamentals of the critical thinking and applying it to new concepts.

Assignment 26: Reading: The computer delusion

http://www.tnellen.com/ted/tc/computer.htm



Oh, haven't we all suffered from the computer delusion at one time or another? Something that will make our life easier ends up taking up more time than if we had just done it the old-fashioned way.



Wasn't it supposed to get rid of the stacks and stacks of paperwork I have to do? Yeah, that's right, where's the paperless society at tax time??!?



The author starts out with this statement:



There is no good evidence that most uses of computers significantly improve teaching and learning, yet school districts are cutting programs -- music, art, physical education -- that enrich children's lives to make room for this dubious nostrum, and the Clinton Administration has embraced the goal of "computers in every classroom" with credulous and costly enthusiasm



He then quotes Newt Gingrich during his time as Speaker of the House, "talking about computers to the Republican National Committee early this year, said, "We could do so much to make education available twenty-four hours a day, seven days a week, that people could literally have a whole different attitude toward learning."



Personally, I think both of those statements clearly indicate what is wrong with the use of technology AND the overall state of our education system. Learning 24-7? How long will be before people hate the site of a computer? Where is the fun in learning? Where is the excitement of learning?



Basically, the author posits that contrary to what pro technology experts say, history is repeating itself but no one is paying any attention (is that surprising in the Rittalin World?)



Five main arguments underlie the campaign to computerize our nation's schools.

  • Computers improve both teaching practices and student achievement.
  • Computer literacy should be taught as early as possible; otherwise students will be left behind.
  • To make tomorrow's work force competitive in an increasingly high-tech world, learning computer skills must be a priority.
  • Technology programs leverage support from the business community -- badly needed today because schools are increasingly starved for funds.
  • Work with computers -- particularly using the Internet -- brings students valuable connections with teachers, other schools and students, and a wide network of professionals around the globe. These connections spice the school day with a sense of real-world relevance, and broaden the educational community.
He then examines each of these issues and offers his criticism. In a nutshell he compares computers to the "filmstrips of the 90s". An interesting comparison when you think of what happened with filmstrips. What he may not realize is that to alot of us who remember filmstrips, we loved them. They were cool -- even the hokey ones. In a worst case situation, it was nap time. The thing is kids will always tune out if they are not interested and engaged, computers are no different in that means (although I believe that they do offer a greater chance for interactive which should be more engaging).

Assignment 25: Digital Diplomas Mills A Desenting Voice

http://www.firstmonday.dk/issues/issue4_7/white/index.html



This is from firstmonday which I used to read abit when I was in "library school".



The author notes the following points:



Where he agrees on the topic of digital diploma mills:

  • Technology is used as a means of social control (e.g., there is a division between those who are pro-technology as a new mechanism for teaching and those who feel that teaching is best served in a traditional setting) As he points out, change is neither good nor bad and does have the ability to breed conflict.

Where he disagrees on the topic of digital diploma mills:

  • The author disagrees on many points of the digital dipolma mills discussion including research into the effectiveness of online teacher, the impact of technology on student performance (critics point to a reduction), it is intrinisically inferior, students do not want it, and that it can never replicate a true teacher/student relationship.

In the remaining part of the article, the author addresses these points and also delivers this stinging commentary, " ...Noble appears to have made it his business not to know much about information technologies."

Frankly, I found both articles very biased, although I did feel the bias was not as pointed in the first article, "Digital Dipolma Mills". In addition to the followup/rebuttal article being personal and subjective, it seemed to be a little too heavy on the "you should believe me because I am an expert" and "do not listen to that man over there because he doesn't even read his email so how could he know anything about online technology?"



Assignment 24: Digital Diploma Mills PT 1

http://communication.ucsd.edu/dl/ddm1.html



Ok, first let me say that I lost my first post on digital diplomas which was long to the blogger monster. I will try to summarize that post below. Also, I am very tired & yucky feeling, so please pardon, any typos.



Basically, this article divides higher ed into two camps:

faculty & students vs. administrators & legislators (for those of us in public institutions)



In other words, learning vs. making money



The author sees the push to digitize learning as just a way to get more people through the door, e.g., the diploma mill. He also discusses the kinds of online programs, and what prestige is attached to various ones.



I thought this was an interesting article, because I have now been a student at UGA through two different administrations. Although, it would seem that fundraising has gained importance, I haven't noticed an incredible shift towards digital learning. In fact, it seems that some of the nontraditional student learning (ALP, Evening Program, etc. have just faded away)











Ohhhh.

Ok, I just finished a big part of my chunk of the webquest assignment (I think). I still need to review the web resources and help out with the evaluation stuff, but the part that is the most important to me is done. I say the most important to me, because it is really the only area of the webquest I feel any competence in. I do not know any high school students. I do not teach and the only classes I have taught have been college freshmen or con't ed kinds of things. I have no clue what appeals to a senior in highschool. In the real world, I would hope to have a little more time to actually ID students to work with and evaluate the content. For the purposes of this assignment, the evaluation of the content is going to be minimal.

/

Tuesday, November 9, 2004

Assignment 22: Reading: Six challenges for educational technology

http://www.virtual.gmu.edu/SS_research/cdpapers/ascdpdf.htm

I think all of these questions are very relative but some are more critical over the long run. Certainly funding up front for computers is needed, and adequate future funding to maintain those computers. However, in the long term support for computers and the technology must come from the community (#4). If parents, legislators, the school board, governing board, etc. can not SEE (understand) the relationships of technology and learning, they will be less likely to support those programs financially.



The second question that I see as very critical over the long run is analysis of student achievement utilizing technology. As technology can provide so many variables, having standards is crucial, especially, in documenting achievement for the purposes of obtaining funding.



Chris Dede (George Mason Univ) sees six challenges for educational technology:

  • How can schools afford to purchase enough multimedia-capable, Internet computers so that a classroom machine is always available for every 2-3 students?
  • How can schools afford enough computers and telecommunications to sustain new models of teaching and learning?
  • How can many educators disinterested or phobic about computers and communications be induced to adopt new technology-based models of teaching and learning?
  • How do we prove to communities that new, technology-based model of teaching and learning are better than current instructional approaches?
  • How can educational technology increase equity rather than widen current gaps between “haves” and “have-nots”?
  • If we use technology well, what should we expect as “typical” student performance?


NOTE

Sorry, I accidentally marked some of my earlier entries draft, so you probably did not see them (if you were looking for them...)

Assignment 23: Reading: Storm Clouds on the Digital Education Horizon

http://www.ascilite.org.au/

conferences/auckland02/proceedings/papers/key_reeves.pdf


Storm Clouds on the Digital Education Horizon



1. Does this shift change the traditional aims of education in our society?

2. What skills will be necessary for success in the Knowledge Age?

3. What have we learned about learning that might help us gain these skills?

4. What does Knowledge Age learning really look like in practice?

5. How do we get there from here- which reform strategy will be effective?

6. How can we best apply learning technologies to support this alternative?



I find the Knowledge Age concept very interesting and I often wonder whether this is a true cultural and societal shift or whether it is just a ripple. Is the Knowledge Age a unique time in history, such as the Industrial Age? or is what is being called the Knowledge Age the beginning of something bigger which we can not articulate at this point? Are we only touching the elephant's left leg?





Friday, November 5, 2004

Assignment 21: Reading: No cliche left behind

http://www.ncrel.org/tech/netc/

2002/keynote.htm


This is a transcript of a speech entitled No cliche left behind: Why Education Policy is NOT like the movies.

In the beginning of the speech, the speaker seems against no child left behind, but then in the end, he seems to have softened his view. The speaker calls the policy, the action hero method of decision making. :) I may have to "borrow" that analogy the next time I am on a committee where people do not want to take the time to come up with a plan.

He points out the challenges that teachers face trying to deal with competing priorities.

He also refers to standardized testing as the "Wizard of Oz" approach to education. Students must

achieve against impossible odds (lack of resources) in order to gain the reward (a passing grade funding for particular things, etc.)



I think this speech does reflect what most people feel about the "no child left behind" --it is a good idea, but poorly implemented and without planning and guidelines, is a terrible.



It's like a lot of things... It's not enough to have a good idea... there must also be a good plan, implementation, and followthrough.



Wednesday, November 3, 2004

Assignment 20: Reading: Diffusions of Innovations

http://www.arches.uga.edu/~bhummel/6200Project/



Within the framework of this project, the group attempts to address the following:



What are the elements of Roger's Diffusion of Innovations Theory?

What stages do adopters pass through from knowledge of an innovation to adoption?

What are some characteristics of adopters of innovations?

What are some attributes of innovations which impact rate of diffusion?

How does Diffusion of Innovations Theory apply to adoption of innovations within household systems?



I found this website very interesting because it really packed in alot of info regarding how innovation happens . As a creative person, I am very interested interested in innovation. When acrylic paint first arrived on the scene (at least to the mass market) it was very much plastic like and very pop art colors. Now acrylic paints mimic oil paint and there are even now hybrid paints.



I won't go into the whole depth of the website but just a few of the basics...



Components (Elements of the theory):



Definition of innovation

According to Roger, innovation is "an idea, practice or object this is perceived as new by an individual or other unit of adoption. (Rogers, 1995)"



Description of how innov ations are communicated among individuals

Innovations can depend upon perception (i.e., the newness of it)



Communication occurs through interpersonal or mass media channels



  • Mass media is quickest while interpersonal is most effective

Description of the role of time in the diffusion process

Time is important to innovation

  • " in the innovation-decision process (stages) where the individual passes from "perception as new" to adoption.
  • in the categorization of individuals as innovators (early adopters vs. late adopters)
  • in the measure of rate of adoption of an innovation which is measured in terms of the number of members in a system which adopt an innovation in a certain time frame"



Definition of a social system

  • is " a set of interrelated units that are engaged in joint problem solving to accomplish a common goal(Rogers, 1995)"
  • act as boundaries for innovation
  • Attributes include: Norms, Change, Agents, Opinion Leaders, Innovation-Decisions, Consequences of Diffusion







Monday, November 1, 2004

Group 3 Assignment WebQuest planning

My group is doing a WebQuest on butterflies, esp. building a butterfly garden.



Wednesday, October 27, 2004

Assignment 19: Reading: a model to guide integration of the WWW as a cognitive tool in k-12

http://it.coe.uga.edu/~treeves/AERA99Web.pdf

A Model to Guide the Integration of the WWW as a Cognitive Tool in K-12 Education by Tom Reeves

Unfortunately, I had a very hard time accessing and printing this document. I'm not sure the fonts were properly embedded into the pdf as it came out all weird. I even printed this one out and had the same results.

I will try again later.

Wednesday, October 20, 2004

Assignment (Response to Readings)

Ok, I did post this to webCT but in order to have an archived copy, I am cross posting.

r



Driving Ms. Daisy into the technology age



One common theme that I found in these posts was the concept of incorporating new interactive media technology in education and learning via distance education. Each of these articles discusses a component or issue of online media. The first article discussed distance learning and the challenges of distance learning. The second article discussed evaluating online resources; the third discussed using the web to teach; and the fourth discussed e-training.



Although it would seem that by definition distance learning would rely heavily on computers and online teaching, it is not a requirement. Distance learning can be as simple as a packet of assignments, a stack of pencils, an envelope and a stamp. However, most distance education programs attempt to harness the interactivity of a classroom via technological tools, such as online chat, real time video, etc.



Certainly, the web can be an important part of distance education. Web and databases with web portals can be a very important part of providing virtual resources for the virtual student. As with any kind of media (print, audio, or electronic), judging the validity of the data is an issue. However, I think the transparency of electronic resources, especially web resources, may offer a unique challenge. However, as web standards increase and metadata becomes more common, this challenge may become less of an issue. It is not that judging the validity of a website is “harder” than judging the validity of the book, it is that it is still a new medium and students have to learn the criteria for evaluation.



Who teaches students in an online environment? E-trainers? Although anyone who works with students online in a teaching environment could be considered an E-trainer, E-training is a corporate model with a specific and defined end result. E-training does not seem to allow for much flexibility in terms of teaching or in developing critical thinking skills, which are very important in academic setting (either K-12 or higher education.)

Although all of these articles discussed aspects of online learning, none spent any significant amount of time on analysis of methods, results, etc. Is this shift in learning and teaching actually a social and cultural shift which has implications beyond education? It would seem that technology and the use of technology has such a great potential to change all aspects of societies that trying to define the impact on education is almost impossible.

Monday, October 18, 2004

Just a note...

Yes, I know my posts are looong. :)

Part of what I am trying to do in my posts is to get down a sense of the fundamentals of the article in order to make use of my blog as a supplement to my classnotes.



Assignment 18: Reading: E-Trainer Evolution

http://www.learningcircuits.org/2001/

jun2001/rossett.html

Expanding Roles of Training Professionals

Conventional roles and skills

  • Design and develop
  • Develop individual brain power
  • Develop content knowledge
  • Deliver or coordinate classes
  • Develop and produce events and products
  • Coordinate short-term events and interactions
  • Deliver from content inventory
  • Share skills and knowledge
  • Focus on employees as learners
  • Measure "butts in seats" and Web hits
  • Reactive problem solving

Future roles and skills

  • Develop and purchase
  • Manage organizational brain power
  • Develop individual learning power, establish associations, find relevant materials, and make meaning
  • Focus on organizational readiness and management of knowledge resources
  • Create and nurture place-bound and online environments that continuously support and develop people
  • Broker systems to be used before and after classes
  • Perform analysis to customize and tailor content
  • Manage knowledge resources
  • Develop programs for managers and students as learners
  • Measure contribution to strategic goals
  • Proactive problem solving

Essentially, this article is predicting that trainers will involve into more of a consultant role where a larger responsibility will be managing e resources and learning opportunities. This new role will be proactive and seems to be a very much in the vein of "give the customer what they want."

Assignment 17: Reading: The World Wide Web: A Technology to Enhance Teaching and Learning?

http://www.edu.yorku.ca:8080/~rowston/article.html



Well, the author starts out the article on a roll with the opening: "Nothing before has captured the imagination and interest of educators simultaneously around the globe more than the World Wide Web...." Umm... Does everyone have access to the web? Noo..... Is this true? Well, that issue is what the author is investigating.



For technology to be useful in education it must

  1. Does it make learning more accessible?
  2. Does it promote improved learning?
  3. Does it accomplish the above while containing, if not reducing, the per unit costs of education?
Does it make learning more accessible?

Examples of making learning more accessible include several online learning program in higher ed, including "virtual universities"; in k-12, home schooling, alternative schooling and extension courses (e.g., AP classes). Problems include technical difficulties, among others.



Does technology promote improved learning?

Essentially, the jury is out on this question. As the field is still relatively young, and studies have yielded mixed or contradicting results, more studies will need to be done and the results of previous studies examined carefully.



Examples as to how the web might improve learning is that it appeals to student interests, it is flexible ;earning and allows different and new kinds of learning.





Does it accomplish the above while containing, if not reducing, the per unit costs of education?

In higher ed the costs are often hidden because the content is developed by faculty. K-12 costs have not been focused on in as much depth. Educators do have an advantage in that there are free resources online. For all technology, there are ongoing costs through equipment, maintenance, software and service.



In conclusion, the author states that "it merits serious consideration." Serious consideration? To be honest, I expected the author to take one side or the other (pro-technology, anti-technology) However, it is a more realistic approach to say that the field is too new to make such sweeping conclusions but it shows much promise.

Assignment 16: Reading: Evaluating Online Educational Materials for Use in Instruction.

http://www.ericfacility.net/ericdigests/ed430564.html



As a librarian one of my favorite topics is how to evaluate good resources. In fact, at a recent user group meeting, one of the speakers talked about the concept of "good enough." In other words, if I know little about stereos and wish to purchase one, I might start at the local giant discount mega retailer. If I find one in the closeout bin that meets my criteria (e.g., receives 2 stations and is silver) then I might buy it regardless of whether there might be a better one on ebay or at an electronics store.



Essentially, what this speaker was saying was that who cares about the quality as long as it meets the expectations of the user! BLEECH! ;(



To be honest, he was probably lucky than librarians are generally nice folks and no one tripped him as he was exiting the stage.



Contrary, to that notion, most librarians believe that researchers/students/patrons should know how to evaluate resources, especially web resources.



This article gives a checklist for determining the worthiness of a website and then suggests some suggested resources on the subject, which are primarily from library edus. :)



The checklist is:

  1. Judge the accuracy of the information and take note of the date modified. Sub-questions to ask yourself:

    a) Does the site provide evidence that it comes from reputable sources?

    b) Does the site contain any obvious biases, errors, or misleading omissions in the document?

    c) Does the site contain advertising that might limit the nature of the content?

    d) Is the information current and up-to-date?
  2. Is the level of information in this site appropriate for the intended audience? Sub-questions to ask yourself:

    a) Does the site contain information appropriate for the intended learners with respect to their maturity and cognitive abilities?

    b) Does the site contain any extraneous and unsuitable vocabulary, language or concepts, bias, or stereotyping?
  3. Is the information in this site presented clearly? Sub-questions to ask yourself:

    a) Is the information arranged in an orderly fashion?

    b) Is the information presented clearly?
  4. Is the information in this site closely related to purpose, content, activity, and procedures? Sub-questions to ask yourself:

    a) Is there a clear tie among the purpose, content, and procedures suggested?

    b) Does the site contain any activities irrelevant to the topic?

    c) Does the site contain any redundant or isolated activities without a relationship to objectives?
  5. Is the information in this site complete in scope and ready for use? Sub-questions to ask yourself:

    a) Does this site contain complete breadth and depth of information related to the topic it claims to cover? b) Are there any content gaps in concept development?
  6. If a website has activities, are the content, presentation method, and learner activity potentially engaging? Sub-questions to ask yourself:

    a) Are the suggested activities challenging, interesting, and appealing for the intended learners? b) Does the information in the site emphasize and promote relevant action on the part of the learner?

    c) Does the site have the potential for developing confidence and satisfaction as a result of learner effort?
  7. If it claims to be comprehensive, is the information in the site well organized? Sub-questions to ask yourself:

    a) Is the information in the site easy to use and logically sequenced, with each segment of the resource related to other segments?

    b) Does the information flow in an orderly manner, use organizing tools (e.g., a table of contents, a map, or headings), and avoid the use of unrelated elements that are potentially ineffective or overpowering?

    c) Are references, bibliographies, or other supporting evidence provided?